xisstential wrote:Looking at the wreckage of the last 10 years one starts to wonder now if Wenger EVER really coached the players. Did he really "create" Henry, Viera, Bergkamp, Pires, Keown, Adams, Cole....etc,etc or were they just a magical,talented bunch who went out and played as they knew how to play. Maybe it wouldn't of mattered if he was there or not?? And for every Henry, there have been half a dozen, Kallstroms, Sanogo's, Bendtners and the like. Very, very occasionally we get a gem and all his supporters rave but the horrendous flops are never mentioned. And how many real journeyman are still on the books on obscene wages?? He buys this shit then sticks with them trying to convince everybody they're gold because if he admits they're crap, what does that make him?? Is there a man anywhere in the world on such good money who is so unaccountable???
I have to agree. We've heard the old players say in their autobiographies that Wenger told them very little, just giving them the 'freedom to express themselves'. We just had a great mix of players with the like of Adams, Keown and Vieira policing the dressing room and giving orders on the pitch. Today, we have nothing in comparison. It's a shame to see a worker like Sanchez surrounded by a bunch of mutes who won't put their body on the line. Our change of style, both in play and players, since 2008 has imploded TOF's reputation.
Henry Norris 1913 wrote:wooo go sean
Yankee_Gooner_Dandee wrote:Don't understand everyone's hate with Ike. His post is 100% accurate.
I have to concur. He's not popular, but it's hard to disagree with him.
beck wrote:Spot on
Thank you
DB10GOONER wrote:arseofacrow wrote:beck wrote:
No I'm not having this revisionism
He was that good
He took a defence that was starting to fail under graham( even rioch steadied the ship in that respect) and gave them a new lease of life
He built the side that went unbeaten but it was towards the end of the 07/08 season where hubris took over and he became Canute like in his failure to adapt with what was needed
He deserved a period to put that right after what he had achieved at the start but to my mind that has gone on over 4 years too long and he should hav been sacked after failing to prepare properly for the 11/12 season after a poor finish to 10/11
To my mind ancelotti should have been installed when he was out of work and reluctant to leave london
But I won't have this slating of everything wenger
He was the right man for the job for over 11 years he just ain't now
I mostly agree here.
I think by 09/10 we'd seen enough, gathered enough evidence and nothing since has changed my mind.
I still can't for the life of me see us winning the league this year.
Me too. Wenger was a brilliant manager in his first 10 years. To say different is just rubbish I'm afraid. I think that perversely the worst thing that happened to us might have been the unbeaten season. I think Wenger lost the plot after that milestone and began to truly believe that he was the Christ Incarnate of football. That's what led to The Project and the obsession with changing the Ingerlish game to tippy tappy.
2008 was the turning point. He bottled the league and went full steam ahead with the failure of Project Youth.
The numerous failures of 2011 - 4-4 at Newcastle, dropping 21 points in the last 11 games to bottle the title for the third time in four seasons, the 8-2 and the terrible start to the 11-12 season - should have seen him sacked, IMO. The club is treading water keeping TOF at the club and we have since endured several humiliating results that would have finished off most managers. Not our 'bank manager' though.
markmark64 wrote:for everything Wenger has done he will always be remembered for not converting us from domestic giants to european giants and with the players he has had at his disposal is sad.
He should have won The Be All and End All with those teams of 2001-05. What are our chances of us ever winning it now?
DB10GOONER wrote:I wouldn't go that far tbh mate. I don't think that's what he'll be remembered for in the media or the wider game. I think he'll be remembered (mostly) for the success he had. But I would absolutely agree the lack of European success is a massive hole in his CV and it does tarnish his managerial career to a certain extent. How much Gooners judge him on that is up to individual Gooners I suppose.
He cannot be considered a 'top-qualitee' manager due to his consistent failure in Europe. His own stubbornness, ego and failure to coach the players (defensively or otherwise) - or let anyone else coach them - has failed him. Overall, he has been exposed and is as big an underachiever as our squads in the Cashburton era have been. He was supposedly an old-school manager when he was at Monaco. His experience in Japan at Grampus helped us in his first decade here, but has massively hindered us since. It is so frustrating
