EC1 wrote: ↑Fri Jan 24, 2025 5:51 pm
Why wouldn’t he seek opinions from players, especially defenders who have played directly against certain forwards.
It would seem an obvious thing to do, it doesn’t mean he will simply then go ahead and buy a player simply based on the opinion of a current player.
Before buying any player, lots of opinions, research will be undertaken.
Unfortunately it seems what ever Arteta does or doesn’t do there are people that criticise, thats life.
It's complete nonsense.
Pep over at Cheaty has just signed 3 players in this window, do you think he consulted with his players, of course not.
Do you think he sought the opinion of his squad when he bought Haaland, of course he didn't.
I can just imagine Arteta calling Havertz and Jesus into his office -
MA - Erm chaps
H&J - Yes boss
MA - I think we need a world class, lethal finishing striker
H&J - Sorry boss?
MA - A new striker
H&J - No, no, no boss. We're good, we don't need any more attacking options. We think you need a goalkeeper and maybe a couple of defensive midfielders.
MA - Gracias, I value your opinion
Although that may explain a few things
You can't ask players their opinion, most can barely tie a shoelace let alone give reasoned opinion.
There is a reason that clubs have scouts, sporting directors and expensive analytical software, and it's not for player's opinions.
And, why is it only us that the press report on this ridiculous shit. You never hear of this nonsense at other clubs. You'd almost think that there was an agenda
And, there is no guarantee that our defenders have played against whoever the striker is that we won't actually buy, or, as is often the case some strikers play better against some defenders than others, so any opinion is completely subjective.
Whatever the case, it's a loaded question by the press to make Arsenteta look completely whacky if no-one else does it.