safcftm wrote:Fact is, most of the people wanting this to happen at Arsenal will be thinking about 3 or 4 thousand fans standing, swearing, jumping about etc- it'd be amazing but the club wont want it so if they're involved they'll find a way of stopping it. They want atmosphere as it helps sell the club to the plastics, but they dont want the type of atmosphere that most fans want as it might put people off- clubs are shit scared of a return to hooliganism and whilst I know thats not what the gooners want at all, and I'm not suggesting thats what you're planning, the club will worry that any fan movement looking to create atmosphere is a step towards it
Surely that should make clubs more in favour of this sort of thing.

That way, (in theory) by congregating as many of the singers/more traditional fans together they get some kind of atmosphere while still allowing the "quiet day out at the footy" types to enjoy said atmosphere from a safe distance.
Main problem is how to ensure the people that get tickets in these sections actually are up for making some noise. It's one thing the club calling it a singing section, but what's to stop anyone from buying a seat there either cos they want to seen to be part of the atmosphere without actually contributing to it, or just cos they want a cheaper lower-tier ticket etc.
That's why the only way I can think of is to make it so some kind of priority is given to fans with x number of away credits - ie for the first 24-48 hours only they can buy in those blocks. Still no guarantee obviously, but proportionally clearly the regular away-goers are more likely to make noise than the rest. Plus since a lot of them will know or at least recognise each other you should get more of a bunch of mates type of atmosphere & camaraderie.
And from the club's point of view, if it entices more of the away-goers back to home games that's more tickets sold for them. You'd think it was a win/win, but as you've said in the past clubs are too short-sighted to see past the end of their own cocks.