Many good points raised and I do agree that it is a very worthwhile cause but I also agree with those that have said that this campaign is doomed to fail

The simple fact here is that the club either dont care about the atmosphere or dont have a fcuking clue how to do anything about improving it and are afraid to consider any fan suggestions in case it dont suit the gestapo policy
If we start at the beginning then we have to cite the use of that wanker and the public address system inside the stadium as a major contributor ion killing the atmosphere. The fact that playing that loud crappy music and that cringeworthy announcing of the players names prevents any fans of getting chants and songs started. For me the atmosphere should start to generate before the match starts and not after kick off - the opposition team should walk out of the tunnel into a hostile atmosphere and not into some kids disco/party setting

If the club want to improve things then restrict this guy's (mc) role on matchday, encourage fans to arrive earlier and at least turn the floor over to those fans to see if they can generate the atmosphere that they talk about and if the fans fail to do so then on their heads be it.
I have to say that I am not sure I agree with have 2 "singing blocks" on opposite ends of the ground - for starters I dont see the point in diluting whatever group willing to initiate the chanting. I also feel, and this is more important imo, that there would be a problem getting both groups singing in unison simply cos of the distance between them and the time delay in the chanting. I think it would make more sense to expand the group into a larger section and put them behind the goals not in some poxy corner of the ground where your influence would be minimal.
I have to say this but what exactly is redaction achieving ? When other issue's have been discussed on here in the past I have been told that they do not fall under redactions remit as their sole aim has been to improve the atmosphere and I am sorry but for me if that is the case then they have failed

How much blame can be attached to the group is up for debate cos as I have said already, I dont really believe the club are willing to do much to help but the bottom line is still that they have by and large achieved little in their quest. They might, with some justification I have to say, point to a lack of backing from the broader community of Gooners but I will always come back to the "pro wenger march" as the most divisive thing that they could have done - there are always moments in time that define what a group/person/organisation stand for and that march done that for me and not in a positive way either and I often wonder that if they could have that time back again would they still do that march ? Anyway for the here and now maybe they will concede that it is time to concede defeat in their efforts and maybe pass the baton onto a different group with new energy cos after all we all want a better atmosphere dont we ?
There are many other points that I could talk about but most have already been covered by others. There is no point in me adding my name to the list simply cos I am not over as much so far this season so my ability to assist would be negligble.