I think luck is a huge part of football, but as you say, you make your own luck and you can't knock Liverpool's CL victory. In a similar way, you can't knock Greece's European Championships triumph, because as you say - you make your own luck, and the history books say Greece won the cup. End of, I suppose.BOJDE LFC wrote: Well he got us to the level that we were getting into the last eight and four of the Champions League every year and finishing one year with our highest points total ever in the Premier League so I would say that that's proof of the quality of players he's brought in. I don't get how luck comes into it, I can imagine if '89 was reversed the amount of 'luck' Liverpool got. Luck is just an excuse when someone can't think of a logical answer. You make your own luck as the saying goes. Look at the amount of own goals that have benefited United this season, they were not all down to 'luck'.
That said, I do think the league is a better indication of a teams quality and progress. As, lets be honest, over 38 games there is NO WAY Greece would have been crowned the best team in Europe... bit over a few cup games, they had a chance. Same goes for Liverpool, as didn't you finish 5th that season?
History shows us that you don't have to be the best team to win a cup (Greece winning the Euro's, Wimbledon & Pompey winning the FA Cup, FC Porto winning the CL, etc) but it's very rare that an average team comes out on top over an entire league season because luck tends to even itself out over long periods and the cream rises to the top (or that's the theory

I think Rafa, for the time and money he's invested, will look back at the 6 years or so he's been at Liverpool and feel he probably either underachieved in the LEAGUE or maybe came out on par.... and certainly not overachieved!
Liverpool have certainly been a very good cup team in recent years, but I'm not sure Rafa was the man to break the 20 year wait for the title, and I honestly think him leaving is a blessing in disguise for Liverpool.
Time will tell, though.