Realistic Replacements for Wenger

As we're unlikely to see terraces again at football, this is the virtual equivalent where you can chat to your hearts content about all football matters and, obviously, Arsenal in particular. This forum encourages all Gooners to visit and contribute so please keep it respectful, clean and topical.
Post Reply
User avatar
OneBardGooner
Posts: 48304
Joined: Sat Apr 04, 2009 9:41 am
Location: Close To The Edge

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by OneBardGooner »

Tomáš wrote:
IW8Goalmachine wrote:I dont see why Klopp gets so much loving on here.

Granted he's a decent manager but look at Dortmund this year
He is the best Manager currently.

Sorry I'm drunk, but it is true...

Thomas one should NEVER EVER apologise for being drunk...seeing as it probably cost you some serious wonga to get in that state - enjoy it and blunder away!.

:cheers:

Supagoon
Posts: 1885
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2011 8:42 pm
Location: Coventry

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by Supagoon »

Well we won't get klopp because timing is wrong. Arsene is having a 'good' season in so much as he has a chance of finishing with a trophy and even avoiding 4th place.

For me I know the guy I want to take over even if it is ambitious. The way I see klopp is, he has a very similar philosophy as Arsene but clearly has less baggage. If he came to Arsenal and won a cup and finished 2nd we'd all be chuffed. Problem we have with the current situation is none of us trust Arsene anymore. I certainly don't.

For me getting Simeone is the more ambitious and tricky move because: A) he has signed a long term contract with Ateltico B) They'll build a new 70k stadium C) he loves atletico.

Simeone is the guy that will ensure we are always prepared to go into matches. He's the guy that make Chelsea fans say: ' **** we have to play Arsenal next'. He will instil discipline and attention to detail that we know we've been missing all these years. Imagine looking forward to a trip (sort of) to OT, not fearing the worst.

Arsene is here at least until the end of the contract and who knows what will have happen with Simeone at Atletico in that time. The stars may just align in time.

I'd puke if he ends up as Mourinho's successor @ Chelsea. :x

User avatar
OneBardGooner
Posts: 48304
Joined: Sat Apr 04, 2009 9:41 am
Location: Close To The Edge

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by OneBardGooner »

Supagoon wrote:Well we won't get klopp because timing is wrong. Arsene is having a 'good' season in so much as he has a chance of finishing with a trophy and even avoiding 4th place.

For me I know the guy I want to take over even if it is ambitious. The way I see klopp is, he has a very similar philosophy as Arsene but clearly has less baggage. If he came to Arsenal and won a cup and finished 2nd we'd all be chuffed. Problem we have with the current situation is none of us trust Arsene anymore. I certainly don't.

For me getting Simeone is the more ambitious and tricky move because: A) he has signed a long term contract with Ateltico B) They'll build a new 70k stadium C) he loves atletico.

Simeone is the guy that will ensure we are always prepared to go into matches. He's the guy that make Chelsea fans say: ' **** we have to play Arsenal next'. He will instil discipline and attention to detail that we know we've been missing all these years. Imagine looking forward to a trip (sort of) to OT, not fearing the worst.

Arsene is here at least until the end of the contract and who knows what will have happen with Simeone at Atletico in that time. The stars may just align in time.

I'd puke if he ends up as Mourinho's successor @ Chelsea. :x

That is a HUGELY important point - only the AKB's and the wig wearer do - for very different reasons. The AKB's because they are mentally retarded and the owner because he knows wenger will make him money/profit - with us paying the price both by being trophyless and paying top dollar.

User avatar
augie
Posts: 30981
Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2007 3:03 pm
Location: Ireland

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by augie »

OneBardGooner wrote:Arsene was (Once Upon a Time) a excellent manager...he still manages to get a team to play creative, entertaining football...BUT..he has many flaws

He pays average ( and below average players) Top Player wages - He has a blindness to their failings - be that in their development, their skills/abilities, their loyalty - and he is too loyal to them - maybe he see's them all as his children or something weird - okay so we all know Ebuoe and Diaby ARE (allegedly) his :wink:

He also spends money in the wrong direction and on players whom he then plays out of their natural, best and strongest position Arshavin being a prime example - He also buys players in positions that we already have in abundance -= Yup he buys mid-field players - but they are all technically gifted, small physically - we need someone in the mid-field who defends ONLY - Okay so it may be a case of he/we lucked out with Coq coming back off loan - But had Arteta & capt Stoopid not been injured - he may never have had the opportunity to prove his worth - which (so far) he has managed to do...whether he has the where-with-all to do it consistently is something we will find out next season.

Wenger is obviously past his best - so an ideal replacement will be a manager who CAN:

Do Tactics - Change the team and playing style to match & beat the opposition
Have a Plan B and C if necessary
Doesn't pander to players (and their scum agents)
Will challenge the board to spend the necessary money in order to win the Prem and CL
Buy the players we need to fill the gaps, rather than paper over them


I know Klopp is good, but for me it is either Ancelloti or Low....

But we are stuck with Wenger for another 2 seasons regardless and if - IF we win the FA Cup it may be longer still..... :?


Methinks that you are being blinded somewhat by our recent good run - we sometimes play entertaining football but much of the time we play tippy tappy sidewards shite :roll: :x

Ikechukwu1
Posts: 1363
Joined: Thu Jun 05, 2014 2:26 pm

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by Ikechukwu1 »

SPUDMASHER wrote:Klopp had a purple patch, Simeone is in the middle of one. Maureen has limitless funding to ensure success. Ancelotti has had a relatively successful career overall, but has never really built a team as he's usually inherited a good starting point. Guardiola has built well at Barca and Bayern but at both clubs has had the funds to do so.

All of them could come to Arsenal and do well but I'm also quite sure that AW could go to their clubs and do quite well too. Management isn't a science. Like players they all have good streaks and bad. As much as I hated the red nosed fucker you can only really say that he is the one manager in my lifetime that has stood head and shoulders above anyone else. He continually re-built Manure over a period of twenty plus years and delivered with alarming regularity.
A "purple patch" that lasted 6 years eh? So do tell, what would you call Lord Arsene's last 10 years? Is this the opposite? Like a "shit patch"? :lol:
Also, does that not also mean AW had a "purple patch" when he had a good few years at the start? What big trophies has he won since? Hmmmm :rubchin: funny how quickly all Wenger replacements are being dismissed. Next I'll be told Jose can "only win with a chequebook" :roll:

markyp
Posts: 3155
Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2012 2:54 pm
Location: location location

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by markyp »

Ikechukwu1 wrote:
SPUDMASHER wrote:Klopp had a purple patch, Simeone is in the middle of one. Maureen has limitless funding to ensure success. Ancelotti has had a relatively successful career overall, but has never really built a team as he's usually inherited a good starting point. Guardiola has built well at Barca and Bayern but at both clubs has had the funds to do so.

All of them could come to Arsenal and do well but I'm also quite sure that AW could go to their clubs and do quite well too. Management isn't a science. Like players they all have good streaks and bad. As much as I hated the red nosed fucker you can only really say that he is the one manager in my lifetime that has stood head and shoulders above anyone else. He continually re-built Manure over a period of twenty plus years and delivered with alarming regularity.
A "purple patch" that lasted 6 years eh? So do tell, what would you call Lord Arsene's last 10 years? Is this the opposite? Like a "shit patch"? :lol:
Also, does that not also mean AW had a "purple patch" when he had a good few years at the start? What big trophies has he won since? Hmmmm :rubchin: funny how quickly all Wenger replacements are being dismissed. Next I'll be told Jose can "only win with a chequebook" :roll:
I think Fergie must of had one hell of a purple patch as he was shit before the last 20 years of his career

User avatar
OneBardGooner
Posts: 48304
Joined: Sat Apr 04, 2009 9:41 am
Location: Close To The Edge

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by OneBardGooner »

augie wrote:
OneBardGooner wrote:Arsene was (Once Upon a Time) a excellent manager...he still manages to get a team to play creative, entertaining football...BUT..he has many flaws

He pays average ( and below average players) Top Player wages - He has a blindness to their failings - be that in their development, their skills/abilities, their loyalty - and he is too loyal to them - maybe he see's them all as his children or something weird - okay so we all know Ebuoe and Diaby ARE (allegedly) his :wink:

He also spends money in the wrong direction and on players whom he then plays out of their natural, best and strongest position Arshavin being a prime example - He also buys players in positions that we already have in abundance -= Yup he buys mid-field players - but they are all technically gifted, small physically - we need someone in the mid-field who defends ONLY - Okay so it may be a case of he/we lucked out with Coq coming back off loan - But had Arteta & capt Stoopid not been injured - he may never have had the opportunity to prove his worth - which (so far) he has managed to do...whether he has the where-with-all to do it consistently is something we will find out next season.

Wenger is obviously past his best - so an ideal replacement will be a manager who CAN:

Do Tactics - Change the team and playing style to match & beat the opposition
Have a Plan B and C if necessary
Doesn't pander to players (and their scum agents)
Will challenge the board to spend the necessary money in order to win the Prem and CL
Buy the players we need to fill the gaps, rather than paper over them


I know Klopp is good, but for me it is either Ancelloti or Low....

But we are stuck with Wenger for another 2 seasons regardless and if - IF we win the FA Cup it may be longer still..... :?


Methinks that you are being blinded somewhat by our recent good run - we sometimes play entertaining football but much of the time we play tippy tappy sidewards shite :roll: :x
True - But we do still play some brilliant (as in entertaining) football - usually when we are a couple of goals to the good...even so we still do - occasionally. Nothing like The Invincibles of course...


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxlV-EG3L-8


:barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf:

User avatar
IW8Goalmachine
Posts: 4575
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 11:15 am
Location: Galway

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by IW8Goalmachine »

OneBardGooner wrote:
augie wrote:
OneBardGooner wrote:Arsene was (Once Upon a Time) a excellent manager...he still manages to get a team to play creative, entertaining football...BUT..he has many flaws

He pays average ( and below average players) Top Player wages - He has a blindness to their failings - be that in their development, their skills/abilities, their loyalty - and he is too loyal to them - maybe he see's them all as his children or something weird - okay so we all know Ebuoe and Diaby ARE (allegedly) his :wink:

He also spends money in the wrong direction and on players whom he then plays out of their natural, best and strongest position Arshavin being a prime example - He also buys players in positions that we already have in abundance -= Yup he buys mid-field players - but they are all technically gifted, small physically - we need someone in the mid-field who defends ONLY - Okay so it may be a case of he/we lucked out with Coq coming back off loan - But had Arteta & capt Stoopid not been injured - he may never have had the opportunity to prove his worth - which (so far) he has managed to do...whether he has the where-with-all to do it consistently is something we will find out next season.

Wenger is obviously past his best - so an ideal replacement will be a manager who CAN:

Do Tactics - Change the team and playing style to match & beat the opposition
Have a Plan B and C if necessary
Doesn't pander to players (and their scum agents)
Will challenge the board to spend the necessary money in order to win the Prem and CL
Buy the players we need to fill the gaps, rather than paper over them


I know Klopp is good, but for me it is either Ancelloti or Low....

But we are stuck with Wenger for another 2 seasons regardless and if - IF we win the FA Cup it may be longer still..... :?


Methinks that you are being blinded somewhat by our recent good run - we sometimes play entertaining football but much of the time we play tippy tappy sidewards shite :roll: :x
True - But we do still play some brilliant (as in entertaining) football - usually when we are a couple of goals to the good...even so we still do - occasionally. Nothing like The Invincibles of course...


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxlV-EG3L-8


:barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf: :barscarf:
Great start to that video. That was a truly magical time for all gooners!

beck
Posts: 595
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 8:19 am

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by beck »

Ikechukwu1 wrote:
gp543 wrote:
Tomáš wrote:
IW8Goalmachine wrote:I dont see why Klopp gets so much loving on here.

Granted he's a decent manager but look at Dortmund this year
He is the best Manager currently.

Sorry I'm drunk, but it is true...
He's not a top 5 manager in world football.

Guardiola, Mourinho, Simeone, Ancelotti and Löw all better.
Why do people keep claiming we need a Top 5 manager? Like we are a Bayern or Real? Lol we just got owned by Monaco in the CL, not challenged for a league title in a decade, and have made 1 CL final in an 18 year stretch. Sounds like some of our fans have ideas above what we are at present :oops:
Also was Wenger a "Top 50" manager ever when he arrived? So who's to say a new manager has to be a Top 5? Klopp, De Boer, Tuchel, Conte etc are all more than good enough. We've never paid more than £20m for a striker and yet are demanding top class managers LOL
It's actually fans like you that has wenger the great underseller of the club very happy
We challenged for the title in 07/08 09/10 and 10/11
The fact that we won none of them was down to poor management from wenger who has allowed an excuse culture to fester at the club that was never the arsenal
Losing or drawing from winning positions in all those 3 seasons in crucial games at crucial times cost us at chelsea and man utd in 07/08
At Birmingham in 08/09 thanks to almunia a goalkeeper that was never good enough in 09/10 and at home to liverpool deep deep into injury time and at spurs with a 2 goal cushion in 10 /11
The famous mental strength he bangs on about is one of the main reasons the title has not been secured for so long
He is very well pad if the job one of the best in world football if it went up today there would a queue round the block for it
We ain't some straw out the mouth hick backwater club but the 3rd most decorated in English football from that little village called london you may have heard of?
(Liverpool only passed us in the 70's utd in the 90's)
I reserve the right to make top class demands n the arsenal thanks very much

beck
Posts: 595
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 8:19 am

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by beck »

augie wrote:I agree with much of that spuddy but I don't think that wenker is as motivated by trophies as other managers are. He could well go to another club and the new challenge might invigorate him and see him return to the manager that he used to be, but in our club he is under no pressure to win trophies and he now value's moral superiority and financial prudence as being more important than trophies :oops: :roll: :evil:
That's about the strength of it I have little doubt that were wenger to take another job he would be a success
He is a very good manager but he has become entrenched in something that is not working at the arsenal
Were he to go somewhere else and our next appointment struggle the careful what you wish for brigade would have a field day
But I don't see fear of what may happen as a reason to stick with something that isn't working
When you replace you go for the best man you think possible for the job
If you get it wrong you go again
We are a very robust club but through history a slightly conservative one
Occasionally the handbrake needs to be removed that time has well and truely passed
I would be only to happy to be wrong after lifting the fa cup again and seeing the necessary measures in place in the summer for a sustained challenge on 4 fronts but we have had too many false dawns to be confident that this will happen
And second is still nowhere even if we do end up getting it
It's only progress if used as such

User avatar
SPUDMASHER
Posts: 10739
Joined: Mon Feb 26, 2007 10:07 am
Location: London Euston
Contact:

Re: Realistic Replacements for Wenger

Post by SPUDMASHER »

Difficult to disagree with the above. Particularly the first two lines.

Post Reply