Jack Wilshere

As we're unlikely to see terraces again at football, this is the virtual equivalent where you can chat to your hearts content about all football matters and, obviously, Arsenal in particular. This forum encourages all Gooners to visit and contribute so please keep it respectful, clean and topical.
Post Reply
User avatar
DB10GOONER
Posts: 62074
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 2:06 pm
Location: Dublin, Ireland.
Contact:

Re: Jack Wilshere: Over-Rated?

Post by DB10GOONER »

Well, that fucking opened the proverbial can of worms! :shock: :lol:

Seriously - won't someone please think of the children!! :cry:

:wink:

Armchair - I was the one that first objected to Hlebby changing the title. But as a mod I also object to you saying we wade in too quickly on here. Most of you would be banned for life from nearly every other forum for posting the stuff you all post on here. And I include all us mods in that too! :wink:

Peace brothers - there are chav$ to beat tonight. 8)

User avatar
I Hate Hleb
Posts: 18632
Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 3:36 pm
Location: London

Re: Jack Wilshere: Over-Rated?

Post by I Hate Hleb »

DB10GOONER wrote:Well, that fucking opened the proverbial can of worms! :shock: :lol:

Seriously - won't someone please think of the children!! :cry:

:wink:

Armchair - I was the one that first objected to Hlebby changing the title. But as a mod I also object to you saying we wade in too quickly on here. Most of you would be banned for life from nearly every other forum for posting the stuff you all post on here. And I include all us mods in that too! :wink:

Peace brothers - there are chav$ to beat tonight. 8)
Don't worry DB10, the forum lawyers are on the case!! 8) (Although whether it would be possible to win the case now that Rolypoly is no longer with us ... :rubchin: ) :wink: :lol: :lol: :wink:

User avatar
augie
Posts: 30870
Joined: Mon Jun 18, 2007 3:03 pm
Location: Ireland

Re: Jack Wilshere: Over-Rated?

Post by augie »

I Hate Hleb wrote:
DB10GOONER wrote:Well, that fucking opened the proverbial can of worms! :shock: :lol:

Seriously - won't someone please think of the children!! :cry:

:wink:

Armchair - I was the one that first objected to Hlebby changing the title. But as a mod I also object to you saying we wade in too quickly on here. Most of you would be banned for life from nearly every other forum for posting the stuff you all post on here. And I include all us mods in that too! :wink:

Peace brothers - there are chav$ to beat tonight. 8)
Don't worry DB10, the forum lawyers are on the case!! 8) (Although whether it would be possible to win the case now that Rolypoly is no longer with us ... :rubchin: ) :wink: :lol: :lol: :wink:


Jesus dont even bring his name up - this thread has sunk low enough without bringing him into the discussion :wink:

clockender1
Posts: 6257
Joined: Wed Nov 15, 2006 5:53 pm

Super Jack

Post by clockender1 »

taking advice from scholes :

http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/27420637

ive been a big critic of him this year, but tbf the comments in this article show some maturity that i've not seen before - the "you can't always blame the injuries" and " not just looking good on the ball" gives me a lot of hope.

and fair play to him for seeking scholes out.

imho if Jack can just go back to basics and keep it simple, keep his head up and look for the easy pass or move into space until another pass is on, rather than running into blind alleys, and attack the box more, that will add a lot to his game - he's got quite the engine but his small size means he does need to avoid getting thumped by the big boys...

if he can learn to play the holding role, he could be quite the partner for Ramsey...

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

Jack was born to play B2B role that Iniesta plays. If anything, Ramsey is the one who's going to have to adapt if Wenger is so insistent in playing this vacuous 4231 when we have no dominant DM...


I also think that Jack has been unfortunate to be playing on the left where we have been unbalanced for quite some time. Gibbs constant ventures forward and with cazorla and podolski always cutting in the inside then forces Wilshere to make do with running at the fullback which restricts his passing opportunities.

Jacks a real problem for CBs when he's running at them full pelt as he stretches the defence for other players to exploit.
Last edited by Ultimatum94 on Thu May 15, 2014 12:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
dPmunky
Posts: 564
Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2012 10:29 pm
Location: Akansas, USA

Re: Super Jack

Post by dPmunky »

he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
Thats a bit harsh. He does need to release the ball quicker but he's a really special talent. Teams know this and set out to take him out every single time as he's that vital bridge from attack to defence.

Wilshere just needs a proficient, big and physical DM alongside him to thrive, like Alex Song, just as Arteta needs Ramsey.

officepest
Posts: 5072
Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2011 12:27 am
Location: Lacking a little bit of sharpness in the final third.

Re: Super Jack

Post by officepest »

Ultimatum94 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
Thats a bit harsh. He does need to release the ball quicker but he's a really special talent. Teams know this and set out to take him out every single time as he's that vital bridge from attack to defence.

Wilshere just needs a proficient, big and physical DM alongside him to thrive, like Alex Song, just as Arteta needs Ramsey.
Please tell me this is tongue in cheek?

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

officepest wrote:
Ultimatum94 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
Thats a bit harsh. He does need to release the ball quicker but he's a really special talent. Teams know this and set out to take him out every single time as he's that vital bridge from attack to defence.

Wilshere just needs a proficient, big and physical DM alongside him to thrive, like Alex Song, just as Arteta needs Ramsey.
Please tell me this is tongue in cheek?
OK maybe not proficient :D :D

But Wilshere's best form coincided alongside Alex Song who did the all the dirty work for him. Arteta isn't the guy who puts himself about on the field and Flamini is far too :banghead: :banghead: :banghead:

clockender1
Posts: 6257
Joined: Wed Nov 15, 2006 5:53 pm

Re: Super Jack

Post by clockender1 »

dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
pretty much this. or he dithers on the ball. either way he slows the game down. Even Arteta keeps the ball moving quicker.

U94- no manager in his right mind would give up Ramsay's shooting ability...

maybe its like Gerrard & Lampard a few years back, maybe these two just can't play together ? - at the moment Ramsay is some way ahead of Jack, as even after his injury he came back very strong.

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

clockender1 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
pretty much this. or he dithers on the ball. either way he slows the game down. Even Arteta keeps the ball moving quicker.

U94- no manager in his right mind would give up Ramsay's shooting ability...

maybe its like Gerrard & Lampard a few years back, maybe these two just can't play together ? - at the moment Ramsay is some way ahead of Jack, as even after his injury he came back very strong.
I think they're more than able to play with each other but it's just with Mesut Ozil, being the 1st name on the teamsheet, there's no way on God's Earth that all 3 would be able to play together without horrifically exposing our defence.

A midfield three of Javi Martinez, Ramsey and Wilshere would be amazing.

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

clockender1 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
pretty much this. or he dithers on the ball. either way he slows the game down. Even Arteta keeps the ball moving quicker.

U94- no manager in his right mind would give up Ramsay's shooting ability...

maybe its like Gerrard & Lampard a few years back, maybe these two just can't play together ? - at the moment Ramsay is some way ahead of Jack, as even after his injury he came back very strong.
I think they're more than able to play with each other but it's just with Mesut Ozil, being the 1st name on the teamsheet, there's no way on God's Earth that all 3 would be able to play together without horrifically exposing our defence.

A midfield three of Javi Martinez, Ramsey and Wilshere would be amazing.

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

clockender1 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
pretty much this. or he dithers on the ball. either way he slows the game down. Even Arteta keeps the ball moving quicker.

U94- no manager in his right mind would give up Ramsay's shooting ability...

maybe its like Gerrard & Lampard a few years back, maybe these two just can't play together ? - at the moment Ramsay is some way ahead of Jack, as even after his injury he came back very strong.
I think they're more than able to play with each other but it's just with Mesut Ozil, being the 1st name on the teamsheet, there's no way on God's Earth that all 3 would be able to play together without horrifically exposing our defence.

A midfield three of Javi Martinez, Ramsey and Wilshere would be amazing.

User avatar
Ultimatum94
Posts: 117
Joined: Wed Apr 16, 2014 3:44 pm
Location: Trapped in Kroenke's hairpeice

Re: Super Jack

Post by Ultimatum94 »

Ultimatum94 wrote:
clockender1 wrote:
dPmunky wrote:he needs to release the ball quicker. for me it looks the same, every game, makes a mad dash upfield with his head down, runs and runs until he sees defenders feet, pulls his head up, releases the ball with only shoelaces to spare and is clobbered by the defender.
pretty much this. or he dithers on the ball. either way he slows the game down. Even Arteta keeps the ball moving quicker.

U94- no manager in his right mind would give up Ramsay's shooting ability...

maybe its like Gerrard & Lampard a few years back, maybe these two just can't play together ? - at the moment Ramsay is some way ahead of Jack, as even after his injury he came back very strong.
I think they're more than able to play with each other but it's just with Mesut Ozil*, being the 1st name on the teamsheet, there's no way on God's Earth that all 3 would be able to play together without horrifically exposing our defence.

A midfield three of Javi Martinez, Ramsey and Wilshere would be amazing.


*I love Mesut Ozil :lol:


P.S. this is the 2nd time my post has tripled. Anyone know the problem?

officepest
Posts: 5072
Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2011 12:27 am
Location: Lacking a little bit of sharpness in the final third.

Re: Super Jack

Post by officepest »

Yes, it's a terrible internet affliction known as spack-hands :wink:

Post Reply