ARSENAL 2009/2010: WHO WOULD YOU SELL WHO WOULD YOU KEEP?

As we're unlikely to see terraces again at football, this is the virtual equivalent where you can chat to your hearts content about all football matters and, obviously, Arsenal in particular. This forum encourages all Gooners to visit and contribute so please keep it respectful, clean and topical.
User avatar
Mr FINSBURY PARK GOONER
Posts: 635
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2008 4:01 pm
Location: Arsenal Country

ARSENAL 2009/2010: WHO WOULD YOU SELL WHO WOULD YOU KEEP?

Post by Mr FINSBURY PARK GOONER »

who would you sell who would you keep


1 GK Manuel Almunia (unsure)
2 MF Abou Diaby (Unsure)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay)
5 DF Kolo Touré (stay)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (WHO ARE YA!!!)(unsure)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay)
9 FW Eduardo (stay)
10 DF William Gallas (unsure)
11 FW Robin van Persie (unsure)
12 FW Carlos Vela (Loan)
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay)
15 MF Denílson (stay)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (loan)
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (BYE)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (loan)
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (unsure)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (BYE)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (unsure)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (stay)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (Loan/unsure)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay)


YES I WANT GREEDY TO P!SS OFF.... I HAD ENOUGH......

User avatar
barnetgooner
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 12:35 am
Location: London

Re: ARSENAL 2009/2010: WHO WOULD YOU SELL WHO WOULD YOU KEEP

Post by barnetgooner »

Mr FINSBURY PARK GOONER wrote:who would you sell who would you keep


1 GK Manuel Almunia (unsure) - KEEP
2 MF Abou Diaby (Unsure) - sell if anyone wants him; it's sad but he's had enough chances
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay) KEEP
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay) KEEP
5 DF Kolo Touré (stay) KEEP
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (WHO ARE YA!!!)(unsure) hmmm
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay) KEEP
9 FW Eduardo (stay) KEEP
10 DF William Gallas (unsure) KEEP
11 FW Robin van Persie (unsure) KEEP
12 FW Carlos Vela (Loan) KEEP - why loan?!
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay) KEEP
15 MF Denílson (stay) KEEP
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (loan) loan
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay) KEEP
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (BYE) SELL
19 MF Jack Wilshere (loan) KEEP
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay) KEEP
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (unsure) KEEP
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay) KEEP
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay) KEEP
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (BYE) SELL if we can get any money for him
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (unsure) KEEP
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (stay) KEEP
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (Loan/unsure) who cares
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay) KEEP


YES I WANT GREEDY TO P!SS OFF.... I HAD ENOUGH......

User avatar
Lethal
Posts: 4612
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2008 11:29 pm

Re: ARSENAL 2009/2010: WHO WOULD YOU SELL WHO WOULD YOU KEEP

Post by Lethal »

1 GK Manuel Almunia (not first choice)
2 MF Abou Diaby (leave))
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay)
5 DF Kolo Touré (not first choice))
7 MF Tomáš Rosický ()(leave)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay)
9 FW Eduardo (stay)
10 DF William Gallas (stay)
11 FW Robin van Persie (unsure)
12 FW Carlos Vela (stay)
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay)
15 MF Denílson (leave)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (loan)
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (BYE)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (loan)
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (leave))
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (die))
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (stay)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (leave)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (Leave)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay)

User avatar
donaldo
Posts: 8175
Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2006 2:33 pm
Location: The gates of hell waiting for Wenger

Post by donaldo »

Out: Rosicknote,RVP,Diaby,Eboue,Bendtner,Denilson and Greedybayor

Almunia 2nd choice keeper

User avatar
goonerboz
Posts: 79
Joined: Wed May 30, 2007 10:35 pm

Post by goonerboz »

NONE OF THEM DESERVE TO WEAR THE SHIRT AND UNTIL THEY SHOW SOME PRIDE ALL ARE UNSURE

User avatar
barnetgooner
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 12:35 am
Location: London

Post by barnetgooner »

donaldo wrote:Out: Rosicknote,RVP,Diaby,Eboue,Bendtner,Denilson and Greedybayor

Almunia 2nd choice keeper
well our striking options would be brilliant if AW followed your plan...

User avatar
selsdon
Posts: 1968
Joined: Mon Apr 14, 2008 3:56 am

Post by selsdon »

Keep:

Arshavin, Cesc, Gallas, Gibbs, Nasri, Clichy, Ramsay, Wilshere

sell:

the rest

User avatar
flash gunner
Posts: 29243
Joined: Tue Nov 06, 2007 6:55 am
Location: Armchairsville. FACT.

Post by flash gunner »

Keep all of them apart from Adecashwhore and then buy 3-4 new experienced over 25 year old players. Defensive midfielder, Goalkeeper, Central defender are critical areas for me followed by a striker to replace Adecashwhore and maybe another central defender.

Before everyone starts saying "but who!!!" i havent got the scouting network Arsene has so let him find the decent players

CelticTiger
Posts: 319
Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2009 10:14 pm
Location: Wicklow

Re: ARSENAL 2009/2010: WHO WOULD YOU SELL WHO WOULD YOU KEEP

Post by CelticTiger »

Mr FINSBURY PARK GOONER wrote:who would you sell who would you keep


1 GK Manuel Almunia
2 MF Abou Diaby
3 DF Bacary Sagna
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas
5 DF Kolo Touré
7 MF Tomáš Rosický
8 MF Samir Nasri
9 FW Eduardo
10 DF William Gallas
11 FW Robin van Persie
12 FW Carlos Vela
14 FW Theo Walcott
15 MF Denílson
16 MF Aaron Ramsey
17 DF Alexandre Song
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre
19 MF Jack Wilshere
20 DF Johan Djourou
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański
22 DF Gaël Clichy
23 MF Andrei Arshavin
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué
28 MF Amaury Bischoff
40 DF Kieran Gibbs
SELL : Gallas,Denilson,Silvestre,Adebayor,Bendtner.

LOAN : Wilshere and Bischoff

BUY : 2 centre backs (solid!) Holding Midfielder,2 Forwards.

as much as i h8 to say alan hansen is right,YOU WIN NOTHING WITH KIDS!!

of all the 5 players i'd like to get for us,make them all aged between 24-30

User avatar
TeeCee
Posts: 9983
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2007 12:26 pm
Location: On the Cusp in SW France

Post by TeeCee »

Let's be honest, the number of players who SHOULD be sold are too numerous so it won't happen. But.....if given my choice....
1 GK Manuel Almunia (DEFINITELY not first choice)
2 MF Abou Diaby (rubbish, has to leave)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay but practice crossing for gods sake)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay)
5 DF Kolo Touré (stay)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (he'll never play again)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay)
9 FW Eduardo (stay, and stay fit for more than one game)!
10 DF William Gallas (Leave)
11 FW Robin van Persie (Leave)
12 FW Carlos Vela (stay)
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay...I'm not convinced tho', too lightweight)
15 MF Denílson (leave)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (stay)
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (past it...seriously)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (stay)
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay, not first choice tho')
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (leave, we need a top no. 1)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (leave...please, just f*** off now)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (stay as a reserve)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (leave)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (Leave)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay)

So that's a squad of 16 players for me! Seriously though, we HAVE to get rid of Adebarndoor as a priority, Diaby has to be right behind him. Gallas is a decent player but will probably leave. Realistically, Wenger will not sell more than two I don't think.
Whatever happens, if we don't sign a quality CB and DM then we can kiss next season goodbye as well. I'm really looking forward to my season ticket renewal dropping through the letterbox shortly. I will renew next season but it is 100% definitely my last if we do not invest in this lightweight squad. I am not going to continue paying over a grand to watch wnakers like Ade saunter around the pitch making 10% effort and being offside 50 times a game.

User avatar
hadareud
Posts: 1202
Joined: Tue Jul 08, 2008 11:50 am
Location: Slough

Post by hadareud »

1 GK Manuel Almunia (stay)
2 MF Abou Diaby (stay)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay)
5 DF Kolo Touré (unsure/sell)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (stay)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay)
9 FW Eduardo (stay)
10 DF William Gallas (stay)
11 FW Robin van Persie (stay)
12 FW Carlos Vela (stay)
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay)
15 MF Denílson (stay)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (stay)
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (sell)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (stay)
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (stay)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (sell)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (stay)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (stay)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (sell)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay)

also:
sell: Traore, Senderos, Simpson and a few other loan players.

buy:
- A first choice centre back in place of either Gallas or Toure (as much as it hurts it will be better if it's Kolo)
- A back up centre back
- An experienced central midfielder ala Alonso (though I doubt he will be available next season)
- A first class replacement for Adebayor

Basically, keep what we have and build on it wisely. We are very close, we do not need surgery, we need to be smart.

Also, promote Barazite and Hoyte into the first team.

If we do that we will have a squad full of quality and a very good mix of experience and youth. You can't really ask for more.

Kevinho
Posts: 1179
Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2008 8:45 pm
Location: Body in Bromley, spirit at Highbury

Post by Kevinho »

1 GK Manuel Almunia (Stay but ONLY as No.2)
2 MF Abou Diaby (Leave, too injury-prone & what the fuck is his best position?)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (Stay, 1st choice RB)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (Stay please but never play behind the striker again, 1st choice CM, give up captaincy)
5 DF Kolo Touré (Stay, reserve CB)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (Leave, we have to cut our losses sadly)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay, 1st choice wide player)
9 FW Eduardo (Stay & get fully fit, 1st choice striker)
10 DF William Gallas (Hope he stays as 1st choice CB but think he'll be off)
11 FW Robin van Persie (Stay, 1st choice striker)
12 FW Carlos Vela (Stay, not sure what he's done wrong these past few weeks, back-up wide player)
14 FW Theo Walcott (Stay but has to convince me he really wants this, 1st choice wide player & back-up striker)
15 MF Denílson (Stay, looks absolutely spent now, reserve CM)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (Stay, reserve CM)
17 DF Alexandre Song (Stay, reserve CM/CB)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (Fuck off)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (Stay, like to see him push for a couple of Prem starts next season at CM)
20 DF Johan Djourou (Stay, reserve CB or even DM)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (Leave, we need a top no. 1. Agree with TeeCee here)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (Stay, 1st choice LB)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (Stay, 1st choice in the Bergkamp role and make him captain. I want to see him unleash hell on the Prem next season)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (Leave, I'm very disappointed in him)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (Stay as a reserve striker NOT on any wing please Arsene!)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (Stay but ONLY as reserve RB)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (WHO?! Fuck right off.)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (Stay as reserve LB, chin up son)


Current loanees;

Philippe Senderos (Stay as 1st CB, give him the chance as Flamini and give him the season to finally prove himself)
Armand Traore (Stay, reserve left winger)
Jay Simpson (Leave, not convinced he'll make it at Arsenal, have only seen him on a few occasions though to be fair)

serk
Posts: 35
Joined: Fri May 30, 2008 12:07 am

Post by serk »

1 GK Manuel Almunia (stay)
2 MF Abou Diaby (stay)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (stay)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (stay)
5 DF Kolo Touré (Stay)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (Sell)
8 MF Samir Nasri (Stay)
9 FW Eduardo (stay)
10 DF William Gallas (Sell)
11 FW Robin van Persie (stay)
12 FW Carlos Vela (stay)
14 FW Theo Walcott (stay)
15 MF Denílson (stay)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (stay)
17 DF Alexandre Song (stay)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (sell)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (stay)
20 DF Johan Djourou (stay)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (stay)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (stay)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (stay)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (sell)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (SELL)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (sell)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (sell)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (stay)

northbankbren
Posts: 4709
Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:47 pm
Location: Im just behind the bloke sitting in front of me.

Post by northbankbren »

BIG CHANGES NEEDED

1 GK Manuel Almunia (SELL)
2 MF Abou Diaby (STAY)
3 DF Bacary Sagna (STAY)
4 MF Cesc Fàbregas (STAY)
5 DF Kolo Touré (STAY)
7 MF Tomáš Rosický (PLAY OR RETIRE)
8 MF Samir Nasri (STAY)
9 FW Eduardo (STAY)
10 DF William Gallas (SELL)
11 FW Robin van Persie (SELL)
12 FW Carlos Vela (STAY)
14 FW Theo Walcott (STAY)
15 MF Denílson (LOAN)
16 MF Aaron Ramsey (LOAN)
17 DF Alexandre Song (SELL)
18 DF Mikaël Silvestre (RETIRE)
19 MF Jack Wilshere (STAY)
20 DF Johan Djourou (STAY)
21 GK Łukasz Fabiański (STAY)
22 DF Gaël Clichy (STAY)
23 MF Andrei Arshavin (STAY)
25 FW Emmanuel Adebayor (KILL)
26 FW Nicklas Bendtner (SELL)
27 DF Emmanuel Eboué (SELL)
28 MF Amaury Bischoff (SELL)
40 DF Kieran Gibbs (STAY)

WE NEED A BETTER SQUAD BIG TIME!!!!!!!!!!!

User avatar
SammyDroppedHisShorts
Posts: 5740
Joined: Sat Mar 28, 2009 10:55 pm
Location: In front of the best fans on earth. The Arse and all.

Post by SammyDroppedHisShorts »

New goalkeeper please...preferably one who covers his near post, or doesnt run off his line a screw up at the shit hole....

Defence....keep Sagna, Gibbs, Clichy, Gallas, Toure and Djorou, get rid of any other defender who is a liability

Midfield.....cherrio Diaby the new Vieira my arse... Denilson to go too lightweight and Rosicky cull him now.
The rest stick about.

Forwards....Adebayor....well..do you think he knows we all hate him? Do you think he actually gives a shit...he has to be HAS TO BE sold...no questions.....the rest...quite frankly.....i couldnt give a hoot.....coz Wenger will always have his "this team has potential" hat on...

Post Reply