Your all time Arsenal XI
-
- Posts: 66
- Joined: Tue May 01, 2007 12:04 pm
BEST
Jennings/Seaman (half each !!)
Anderson
Adams
O'Leary
Sansom
(how odd that I have chosen so few of arguably the greatest back 4 in English history)
Rocastle
Vieira
Brady
Pires
Henry
Bergkamp (for me the greatest Arsenal player ever)
Close but no cigar to Campbell, Wright, Petit, Overmars
Notable mention to Supermac, just because I idolised him when a kid.
WORST
Barnett
Stepanovs
Mancini
Caton
Ceaser
(clearly struggling for full-backs !!)
McGoldrick
Hillier
Helder
Hawley
Hankin
Chapman (pretty scary that all three strikers were at the club at around the same time trying to fill Stapleton's boots - great days eh !!)
Jennings/Seaman (half each !!)
Anderson
Adams
O'Leary
Sansom
(how odd that I have chosen so few of arguably the greatest back 4 in English history)
Rocastle
Vieira
Brady
Pires
Henry
Bergkamp (for me the greatest Arsenal player ever)
Close but no cigar to Campbell, Wright, Petit, Overmars
Notable mention to Supermac, just because I idolised him when a kid.
WORST
Barnett
Stepanovs
Mancini
Caton
Ceaser
(clearly struggling for full-backs !!)
McGoldrick
Hillier
Helder
Hawley
Hankin
Chapman (pretty scary that all three strikers were at the club at around the same time trying to fill Stapleton's boots - great days eh !!)
- U.F.G Anfield '89
- Posts: 1712
- Joined: Sun Jan 14, 2007 7:26 pm
- Location: Royal Holloway University of London
with my bad team selection i've decided to do something a little different, i have included one player in each position that is a present or former Arsenal legend but considering them on the basis of how shit they were at the start or the end of their arsenal career, these players will have in brackets what point in their career when they were shit.
GK) Seaman (the one that lost us the title in '03)
DF) Kolo (anyone remember the horror that was left back Kolo in his first season for us? how the hell is that the same player we have now?)
DF) Cygan
DF) Stephanovs
DF) Ceasar
MF) Parlour (pre wenger era)
MF) McGoldrick
MF) Helder
MF) Hillier
FD) Henry (first few games for us, Shocking!)
FD) Aliadiaire
GK) Seaman (the one that lost us the title in '03)
DF) Kolo (anyone remember the horror that was left back Kolo in his first season for us? how the hell is that the same player we have now?)
DF) Cygan
DF) Stephanovs
DF) Ceasar
MF) Parlour (pre wenger era)
MF) McGoldrick
MF) Helder
MF) Hillier
FD) Henry (first few games for us, Shocking!)
FD) Aliadiaire
-
- Posts: 1869
- Joined: Sun Feb 18, 2007 6:09 pm
Best
GK - David Seaman
DR - Pat Rice
DL - Silviniho
DC - Tony Adams
DC - David O' Leary
ML - Marc Overmars
MC - Patrick Viera
MC - Liam Brady
MR - Robert Pires
FC - Ian Wright
FC - Thierry Henry
Subs: Kenny Sansom, Dennis Bergkamp, David Rocastle, Kolo Toure, Pat Jennings
Worst
GK - Vince Bartram
DR - Gus Caesar
DC - Jeff Blockley
DC - Terry Mancini
DL - Ashley Cole
MR - Mark Flatts
MC - Gilles Grimandi
MC - David Hillier
ML - Glenn Helder
FC - Lee Chapman
FC - Perry Groves
GK - David Seaman
DR - Pat Rice
DL - Silviniho
DC - Tony Adams
DC - David O' Leary
ML - Marc Overmars
MC - Patrick Viera
MC - Liam Brady
MR - Robert Pires
FC - Ian Wright
FC - Thierry Henry
Subs: Kenny Sansom, Dennis Bergkamp, David Rocastle, Kolo Toure, Pat Jennings
Worst
GK - Vince Bartram
DR - Gus Caesar
DC - Jeff Blockley
DC - Terry Mancini
DL - Ashley Cole
MR - Mark Flatts
MC - Gilles Grimandi
MC - David Hillier
ML - Glenn Helder
FC - Lee Chapman
FC - Perry Groves
Last edited by Cus Geezer on Thu Sep 06, 2007 7:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 150
- Joined: Wed Nov 08, 2006 1:50 pm
- Location: nottingham
- EdgeOfTown
- Posts: 473
- Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2007 9:13 am
right I'm still a youngster so can only go on players I've seen in the flesh, obviously cant put Brady/Graham or any of the old guard...
Seaman
A.Cole (
)
T.Adams
K.Toure
Ralph
Pires
Overmars
Vieira
Cesc
Bergkamp
Henry
too many players to leave out so I'll make a bench too...
Mad Jens
Manu Petit
Keown
Overmars
M.Thomas (for THAT goal- 1st Arsenal memory..)
Ian Wright, Wright, Wright
Perry Groves (number 1,2,3,4,....)
RvP
Seaman
A.Cole (




T.Adams
K.Toure
Ralph
Pires
Overmars
Vieira
Cesc
Bergkamp
Henry
too many players to leave out so I'll make a bench too...
Mad Jens
Manu Petit
Keown
Overmars
M.Thomas (for THAT goal- 1st Arsenal memory..)
Ian Wright, Wright, Wright
Perry Groves (number 1,2,3,4,....)
RvP
- Cockerill's chin
- Posts: 1278
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 12:57 pm
- Location: Found the transfer fund... in Bendtner/Diaby/Denilson's pockets
Can't put the likes of Bastin in as I never saw him, but my eleven and subs are:
GK - Jennings
LB - Winterburn
CB - Adams
CB - O'Leary
RB - Sansom
LM - Overmars
MF - Rocastle
MF - Brady
RM - Pires
FW - Bergkamp
FW - Henry
Subs: Seaman, Keown, Vieira, Merson, Wright, George.
Worst ever players would be bootboys/batchcleaners:
Caesar (sorry Gus), McGoldrick, Jensen, Nicholas
GK - Jennings
LB - Winterburn
CB - Adams
CB - O'Leary
RB - Sansom
LM - Overmars
MF - Rocastle
MF - Brady
RM - Pires
FW - Bergkamp
FW - Henry
Subs: Seaman, Keown, Vieira, Merson, Wright, George.
Worst ever players would be bootboys/batchcleaners:
Caesar (sorry Gus), McGoldrick, Jensen, Nicholas
- dvbrisgooner1
- Posts: 1305
- Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2007 5:30 pm
- Location: here and there
I can only base my team on players I have seen (I have been going since 1982/83). My best team is:
David Seaman
Lee Dixon
Nigel Winterburn
Tony Adams
Martin Keown
David Rocastle
Patrick Vieira
Manu Petit
Robert Pires
Thierry Henry
Dennis Bergkamp
Subs: Jens Lehmann, David O'Leary, Anders Limpar, Ian Wright, Paul Davis.
My worst team (really difficult)
Vince Bartram
Matthew Rose
Gio Van Bronckhorst (playing at left-back)
Pascal Cygan
Igors Stepanovs
Eddie McGoldrick (the worst player ever at Arsenal)
Alberto Mendez
Ian Selley
Jimmy Carter
Julio Baptista
Martin Hayes (post 1987)
David Seaman
Lee Dixon
Nigel Winterburn
Tony Adams
Martin Keown
David Rocastle
Patrick Vieira
Manu Petit
Robert Pires
Thierry Henry
Dennis Bergkamp
Subs: Jens Lehmann, David O'Leary, Anders Limpar, Ian Wright, Paul Davis.
My worst team (really difficult)
Vince Bartram
Matthew Rose
Gio Van Bronckhorst (playing at left-back)
Pascal Cygan
Igors Stepanovs
Eddie McGoldrick (the worst player ever at Arsenal)
Alberto Mendez
Ian Selley
Jimmy Carter
Julio Baptista
Martin Hayes (post 1987)
Not much original here, but has anyone else noticed that lots of George Graham's 1990s signings make the "worst" lists? Says a lot for what he did post 1991.
Best:
GK - Jennings
LB - Clichy
CB - Adams
CB - O'Leary
RB - Dixon
LM - Pires
CM - Vieira
CM - Fabregas
RM - Brady
ST - Henry
ST - Bergkamp
Worst:
GK - Wood
LB - Cygan
CB - Caton
CB - Stepanovs
RB - Ceaser
LM - Helder
CM - Song
CM - Hillier
RM - Carter
ST - Jeffers
ST - Baptista
Best:
GK - Jennings
LB - Clichy
CB - Adams
CB - O'Leary
RB - Dixon
LM - Pires
CM - Vieira
CM - Fabregas
RM - Brady
ST - Henry
ST - Bergkamp
Worst:
GK - Wood
LB - Cygan
CB - Caton
CB - Stepanovs
RB - Ceaser
LM - Helder
CM - Song
CM - Hillier
RM - Carter
ST - Jeffers
ST - Baptista
- dvbrisgooner1
- Posts: 1305
- Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2007 5:30 pm
- Location: here and there
I have made a huge mistake on my worst team and I have to apologise to Ian Selley - if you ever read this Ian, please note that I am sincerely sorry and take it all back. I forgot (and so did most by the looks of it) about STEFAN MALZ!dvbrisgooner1 wrote: My worst team (really difficult)
Vince Bartram
Matthew Rose
Gio Van Bronckhorst (playing at left-back)
Pascal Cygan
Igors Stepanovs
Eddie McGoldrick (the worst player ever at Arsenal)
Alberto Mendez
Ian Selley
Jimmy Carter
Julio Baptista
Martin Hayes (post 1987)
Message to "collins" - anyone who saw Gio play at left-back for us will know why I selected him there!
- All_Arsenal_1886
- Posts: 1785
- Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2007 3:32 pm
- Location: South London/Benalmadena
- Contact:
I only picking players since 1997/98 season because tha was the season i had my first game
GK - D.Seaman
RB - L.Dixon
CB - T.Adams
CB - K.Toure
LB - N.Winterburn (I just couldn't put Cashley in)
RM - F.Lungburg
CM - C.Fabregas
CM - P.Vieira
LM - M.Overmars
CF - D.Bergkamp
CF - T.Henry
Subs,
GK - J.Lehmann,
DEF - G.Clichy,
MID - R.Pires,
MID - R.Van Persie,
ST - I.Wright.
Bloody hell that was harder than i thought and i was only choosing from the last 10 years.


GK - D.Seaman
RB - L.Dixon
CB - T.Adams
CB - K.Toure
LB - N.Winterburn (I just couldn't put Cashley in)
RM - F.Lungburg
CM - C.Fabregas
CM - P.Vieira
LM - M.Overmars
CF - D.Bergkamp
CF - T.Henry
Subs,
GK - J.Lehmann,
DEF - G.Clichy,
MID - R.Pires,
MID - R.Van Persie,
ST - I.Wright.
Bloody hell that was harder than i thought and i was only choosing from the last 10 years.


Last edited by All_Arsenal_1886 on Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 637
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 3:45 pm
- Location: LONDON
- All_Arsenal_1886
- Posts: 1785
- Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2007 3:32 pm
- Location: South London/Benalmadena
- Contact:
Cheers ECD, my badEboue Can't Defend wrote:All Arsenal 1886,
You've got your Left and Right Backs the wrong way around!!![]()
![]()
![]()
Having watched Arsenal since the late sixties, this is much too difficult for me so I'm not even going to attempt to pick a team. Unless, of course, it consists of at least 30 players!!![]()
![]()

