How dare you have an opinion - humble or otherwise. I bet you haven't even worked half a day in football ?Pilly wrote:Subotic from Dortmund would be a far better signing in my humble opinion.Chips and Chocolate wrote:Samba or Cahill might not be all that but at least they would be reliable additions ready for the PL. And our international scouting system has not be that efficient in the last few years, has it?tonysaunders wrote:Possibly, but I'd hope that our international scouting system would be able to identify two better players than Cahill or Samba. Just because the papers keep saying Cahill and Samba (based on no real information at all), doesn't mean that that's what we need to settle for. Remember, Man Utd spent £16 million on Phil Jones. If Cahill or Samba were that good you'd expect United to by first in the queue, wouldn't you? As it stands, there doesn't really seem to be interest from anyone else yet (again, according to paper talk).Chips and Chocolate wrote:I agree on Vermaelen! Koscielny, while not bad, is not ready to be in the first XI. Playing Cahill or Samba alongside big Tom + replacing Clichy is a must in my opinion!tonysaunders wrote: Whilst I think that we do need to buy a centre half or two, I'm not sure that's necessarily the problem. Vermalen is a class defender and Koscielny and Djourou aren't bad players. In my opinion, the problem isn't so much personnel, it's the way they're coached. It's hard to judge because you can't quite put your finger on what exactly is wrong, but it seems like bad decisions are made - a lot. There's always one player who forgets to squeeze up when they're trying to play offside or there's always one player napping when a free kick comes in.
The defence needs organising and I'm not sure Wenger is the one to do it. He's not going anywhere until the end of his contract (sorry, but it's true) so the only thing I can think of is getting some kind of defensive coach.![]()
Anyway, I'm no football manager. Let's enjoy the 2nd half!
HANGZHOU GREENTOWN OFFICIAL THREAD
- StuartL
- Posts: 7878
- Joined: Sat May 17, 2008 8:22 pm
- Location: It’s a new dawn, a new day a new life, for me and I’m feeling good
- Chips and Chocolate
- Posts: 1518
- Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2009 11:48 am
- Location: N7
I've heard people talking about him yeah but then again I've got limited knowledge of European football!Pilly wrote:Subotic from Dortmund would be a far better signing in my humble opinion.Chips and Chocolate wrote:Samba or Cahill might not be all that but at least they would be reliable additions ready for the PL. And our international scouting system has not be that efficient in the last few years, has it?tonysaunders wrote:Possibly, but I'd hope that our international scouting system would be able to identify two better players than Cahill or Samba. Just because the papers keep saying Cahill and Samba (based on no real information at all), doesn't mean that that's what we need to settle for. Remember, Man Utd spent £16 million on Phil Jones. If Cahill or Samba were that good you'd expect United to by first in the queue, wouldn't you? As it stands, there doesn't really seem to be interest from anyone else yet (again, according to paper talk).Chips and Chocolate wrote:I agree on Vermaelen! Koscielny, while not bad, is not ready to be in the first XI. Playing Cahill or Samba alongside big Tom + replacing Clichy is a must in my opinion!tonysaunders wrote: Whilst I think that we do need to buy a centre half or two, I'm not sure that's necessarily the problem. Vermalen is a class defender and Koscielny and Djourou aren't bad players. In my opinion, the problem isn't so much personnel, it's the way they're coached. It's hard to judge because you can't quite put your finger on what exactly is wrong, but it seems like bad decisions are made - a lot. There's always one player who forgets to squeeze up when they're trying to play offside or there's always one player napping when a free kick comes in.
The defence needs organising and I'm not sure Wenger is the one to do it. He's not going anywhere until the end of his contract (sorry, but it's true) so the only thing I can think of is getting some kind of defensive coach.![]()
Anyway, I'm no football manager. Let's enjoy the 2nd half!
- Captain Fabregas
- Posts: 4444
- Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:36 pm
- Location: UK
- rodders999
- Posts: 22750
- Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 1:59 pm
- Location: Diamond Club
...though don't get me wrong, I'd happily settle for Samba and/or Cahill!Chips and Chocolate wrote:I've heard people talking about him yeah but then again I've got limited knowledge of European football!Pilly wrote:Subotic from Dortmund would be a far better signing in my humble opinion.Chips and Chocolate wrote:Samba or Cahill might not be all that but at least they would be reliable additions ready for the PL. And our international scouting system has not be that efficient in the last few years, has it?tonysaunders wrote:Possibly, but I'd hope that our international scouting system would be able to identify two better players than Cahill or Samba. Just because the papers keep saying Cahill and Samba (based on no real information at all), doesn't mean that that's what we need to settle for. Remember, Man Utd spent £16 million on Phil Jones. If Cahill or Samba were that good you'd expect United to by first in the queue, wouldn't you? As it stands, there doesn't really seem to be interest from anyone else yet (again, according to paper talk).Chips and Chocolate wrote: I agree on Vermaelen! Koscielny, while not bad, is not ready to be in the first XI. Playing Cahill or Samba alongside big Tom + replacing Clichy is a must in my opinion!![]()
Anyway, I'm no football manager. Let's enjoy the 2nd half!
- Captain Fabregas
- Posts: 4444
- Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2008 9:36 pm
- Location: UK
- rodders999
- Posts: 22750
- Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 1:59 pm
- Location: Diamond Club
I'm looking forward to seeing Wilshere. And Ramsey. And Gibbs will be interesting if we don't replace Clichy. And Gervinho will be interesting as he's our major signing so far. And Van Persie, if he can stay fit and keep scoring. And Vermaelen.Captain Fabregas wrote:Ryo is the only player i'm looking forward to watching next season.
And yes...Ryo too (depending on him getting a work permit that is!

- rodders999
- Posts: 22750
- Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 1:59 pm
- Location: Diamond Club